Critical Analysis Of Rostows Stages Of Growth

Rostow’s rates of outaugmentation speculation saw outaugmentation as a rectirectirectistraight appoint lower which exoteric economies would educe lower a set of all antecedent sordid to perfect province. Far from such fancyhither creature were not barely the interexoteric augmentment (outer actors, strange cannonade, stipulations of occupation) but to-boot the stipulations that indicate and weigh-down the footfootroute to outaugmentation of incongruous countries.

Among those are the commemorative stipulations which, according to a fields of economic conceit (neo-marxist and structuralist), set the weigh-downts that sundry countries countenance in the appoint of outgrowth. Indeed, the gap betwixt the educeed and educeing countries may be explained having into averment commemorative determinations (including the Colonial Empires, Industrial Revolution, and lowerneath it all, the appoint of store of excellent and sway by the industrialized countries) that led to such disparities. In this sensation, the “backward” countries don’t possess the selfselfcongruous stipulations for outaugmentation that industrial countries had, and thus the rectirectirectistraight rates of outaugmentation that Rostow intended do not appear ostensible. How can incongruous countries astern a while a incongruous set of commemorative stipulations supervene the selfselfcongruous footfootroute to outgrowth?

Yet, flush today, economic aid policies are centered on the allity of goals and its media in dishabit of the variation and commemorativeal elucidation of countries. Policy packages containing notorious strategies and tools are repeatedly suggested (or imposed) to incongruous educeing narrates – the implementation of the structural combination policies and its consequences are test of such.

In capricious of that, I establish that outaugmentation policies in notorious possess been superveneing Rostow’s standapex on rectilinearity, allity and objectivity, neglecting the incongruous detailities and weigh-downts of countries. In my apprehension, the reflecting on commemorative stipulations of outaugmentation is determinant as it causes tail a detail and contextualizing mode to outgrowth.

The rectilinearity of Rostow’s Stages of Outaugmentation and the stipulations of outgrowth

The speculation

In the year of 1960 Walt Whitman Rostow published a exertion that would not barely befit puissant in the studies of outgrowth, but to-boot perfectly controversial, remarkable deliberate on the stipulations of outgrowth.

In this exertion, Rostow educeed a rectirectirectistraight in, according to which perfect province would by through the selfselfcongruous rates aggravate occasion and flushtually arrive-at a equalize of competent and sustainable outgrowth. Tnear are five rates of outgrowth, according to Rostow: the transmitted participation rate; the modifiable rate; the accelerate to manliness rate; and the tall bulk deccord rate.

Under the transmitted participation, economic zeal is poor to patronage astern a while the output (cattle, fish, encumber, etc.) entity quickly consumed by those who remainder it. The arrangement is thus, centered on plain wants and not on occupation, entity erected by labour intensive activities such as farming, fishing, hunting and logging. When the participation gains the pre-stipulations 1 for grasp off but has not yet entered a side of tall outgrowth, it arrive-ates the modifiable rate. Lower this side, trading befits a admissionible economic zeal, astern a while the entrepreneurs proper an emergent arrange. Investments and savings consort the increases in pay and a bliss infraerection educes, maximizing the outcomes of occupation and facilitating its interdiplomaticization.

Eventually, the stipulations for secure outaugmentation grasp situate and the participation enters the grasp off rate, set-on-footing to industrialize, astern a while the labour progressively entity communicated from craftsman and agricultural activities to manufacturing. Supporting this appoint of industrialization are the new ordinary collective and collective institutions.


1 The erector does not execute on these pre-conditions, referring to them merely as the pre-requisites for secure outgrowth. Tnear are a lot of profession criticizing the disrepute of Rostow’s speculation, affect Baran, Hobsbawn (1961)

Growth is self-sustaining and close in indubitable regions and few industries. When the arrangement set-on-foots to change-modify, the participation arrive-ates the accelerate to manliness rate. Lower this side, technological novelty provides multiple cannonade opportunities, induced to a mixed erectation of movables and services, decreasing the trust on imports. Such flushtually accomplish plain to a consumer participation, what Rostow designates by Tall Bulk Deccord Stage.

Shaping outaugmentation astern the western habit

Rostow’s speculation was criticized for entity too undetermined and fancyless. It lieed countries as homely entities, whose outaugmentation was not biasd by outer actors nor by the stipulations of occupation. Thus, the speculation proved to be perfectly unpractical and unrealistic in a earth mouldd by interexoteric forces (let it be the financial negotiates, occupation dynamics or nonresidence flows).

But possibly the apex that led to advance contention was the stipulations of outgrowth. As previously ordinary, Rostow does not execute on what are the pre-stipulations ordinary in the modifiable rate and the stipulations for grasp off. Yet, he does aver that the ocean engines for economic outaugmentation are savings and cannonade. If a province was denial a financial gap (withdrawal of savings and thus, low cannonades), it could spin into a admitr of outer aid which would aid neutralize such gap. This establishedty was grounded oceanly on the Marshall Pur-pose which, according to Todaro (2002), succeeded barely owing the beneficiaries collected a reckon of stipulations (exposed bliss facilities; trained exertionforce; integrated negotiate; etc) which allowed the alteration of new excellent into taller equalizes of output in an causative way.

Indeed, outaugmentation policies in sundry events possess continued a in that is founded in the plain examine of the most educeed economies, recognizeing that the poopeace countries today should supervene the selfselfcongruous footfootroute to outaugmentation as did the now richest narrates.2


2 It is thrilling to wordslessness that flush Marx believed societies had to by through excellentism in appoint to finish economic outgrowth. In his own signification “The province that is advance educeed industrially barely exhibitions to the hither educeed the fancy of its own future”. See Hunt (1989)

Yet, outaugmentation practitioners appear to lose that the stipulations for outaugmentation are not equal- for request, at the occasion of their industrialization, the western countries were able to localize the ample regular media habitous in the poopeace countries (Furtado, 1974).


Here lies the ocean quantity of Rostow’s rectirectirectistraight erectwork- it arrogates the creature of the selfselfcongruous stipulations of outaugmentation in incongruous countries, aggravatelooking the animosity and variation that mould perfect narrate and are intrinsically stable to the intepeace of outgrowth.

In circumstance, tnear is no rectirectirectistraight prospering that can mix itself to the narrative of perfect province. When one defends that perfect arrangement must supervene the selfselfcongruous cord of outgrowth, one is aggravatesimplifying the complexity of the forces of outaugmentation (Meier, 1976).

In faithfulness, Rostow’s speculation does not aid us to lowerstand the economic and collective stipulations of a province, or to habit out advance environing its possibilities and perspectives of outgrowth. In appoint to deeply lowerstand the complexities of outaugmentation one wants to examine the incongruous stipulations (arising from narrative, culture, geography, etc) that the countries are compensated astern a while.

The stipulations of outgrowth

Todaro (2002) enumerates the superveneing structural differences betwixt countries: commemorativeal elucidation ; size; endowments of media ; ethic and divine settlement; weight of notorious and secret sectors; character of industrial sector; rate of reliance on outer circumstanceors; dispensation of sway; institutional and collective erection.

All of these conduce to shaping narrates in a singular way, giving them strengths and weaknesses that can barely be lowerstood having into averment the incongruous characteristics and stipulations of incongruous countries. But let us standapex on the “literal elucidation”.

If we seem tail to the Industrial Rdisconnection and the appoint of economic outaugmentation of the western countries and parallel it to the augmentment educeing countries countenance today, we see that tnear is perfectly a incongruous scenario.

For request, industrializing countries of the XIX Century were economically in track of the peace of the earth and thus could grasp habit of their solid financial lie to expatiate the pay gaps betwixt them and the poopeace countries. Conversely, today’s educeing countries set-on-foot the appoint of economic outaugmentation in an impertinent locate, loitering astern the most educeed countries (Todaro, 2002). In the selfselfcongruous sensation, western countries during the Industrial Rdisconnection were far afore in stipulations technological novelty which boosted and mixed their economies. In today’s earth, the poopeace countries countenance a excellent dishabit in stipulations of technology, entity contingent on imports from the richest countries (Todaro, 2002).

The doubt environing the commemorative stipulations of outaugmentation has been the standapex of regard by sundry erectors, congenial from economic schools such as structuralism and neo-marxism.

The commemorative stipulations of outaugmentation 3

Structuralists such as Furtado and Sunkel complete that the admissionible features of loweroutaugmentation are interlinked astern a while the commemorative appoint of outaugmentation of the now richest narrates. In that sensation, loweroutaugmentation can be seen as a inequitable commemorativeal mood. (Hunt, 1989)

According to Furtado (1974), tackling the entity of loweroutaugmentation is not an lenient task: tnear are sundry exertion and those that are manifest are not regularly the most momentous. Above all, what lies lowerneath the appoint of economic outaugmentation is the equalize of store of excellent applied to the prolific appointes and the equalize of admission to the decisive movables that featureize modernization.


3 It is exalted to emphasis that near, commemorative stipulations are to be interpreted as commemorativeal flushts (e.g: Industrial Revolution, Colonialism, Slave Trade, etc) that possess mouldd societies in stipulations of variation and singularness and are intrinsically connected to the rule a province has to finish outgrowth. It should not be chaotic astern a while Marx’s commemorative materialism which in stipulations of erect can be paralleld to Rostow’s rates of outgrowth, in the way it proposes a rectirectirectistraight appoint in which societies eliminate. See Hunt (1989) and Moreira (1978)

The excellent transformations of the XIX Century occurred concurrently two appointes: the acceleration of the store of excellent and the intensification of interexoteric occupation. Twain these appointes generated increases in drudge productivity, induced to growing tarryder which were localized to advance inflame the appoint of store and to finance the diversification of secret and notorious decline. It was by appropriating that tarryder, that England consolidated the implementation of a appoint of interexoteric dissolution of drudge, which would mould the disconnection of industrial excellentism. Such would flushtually indicate the necessity of the poopeace countries in stipulations of prospects for outgrowth, astern a while the appoint of store of excellent by the industrialized narrates expatiateing the gap betwixt poopeace and richest.

In a congruous erect of conceit, neo-marxists affect Baran complete that concurrently the appoint of industrialization of the western economies, the poopeace countries were threaten into a appoint of uneven change, making them contingent on advance swayful narrates, and in a weaker lie to set-on-foot their own appoint of outgrowth. These weigh-downs are peaceful manifest today. In his own signification: “… the forces that possess finished the necessity of the tailward earth peaceful employment a swayful application on the stipulations most-notorious at the bestow occasion. Their erects possess transitional, their intensities are incongruous today; [yet] their rise and plainion possess tarryed unaltered. They coerce now as they possess coerceled in the gone-by the destinies of the lowerdeveloped…” (Baran, 1957)

All in all, notwithstanding attempts at modeing outaugmentation in a all and rectirectirectistraight way, it is neither likely nor substantive to harness the inequitableities of a province entrance into averment notorious fancys, ancilla to any creature. Such modees do not possess into averment the stipulations that indicate and weigh-downt the footfootroute to outaugmentation of incongruous countries. Yet, to this day, they are peaceful entity applied, and their aptitude tarrys doubtable.

Economic aid policies: allity of goals, bearing of media

Perhaps biasd by the rectilinearity and flourishing a whiledrawal of standapex of theories such as the rates of outgrowth, today’s economic aid policies are centered on allity goals, while the media are perfectly homogenous, astern a while scanty regard entity consecrated to the incongruous detailities of societies.

Indeed, notwithstanding the variation and commemorativeal elucidation of incongruous narrates, aid packages containing the selfselfcongruous notorious strategies and tools are implemented in several countries. Furthermore, these packages are repeatedly accompanied astern a while moodalities- a province is barely preferable for financial aid if it supervenes a set of stipulations (usually a reckon of policies)- which very repeatedly do not possess into averment the inequitableities of the economies in which they are going to be implemented. One intelligible in of that are the structural combination policies.

Structural Combination Policies: the inaptitude of big layer reforms

Structural combination hypothecations were born lower the instruct of Earth Bank principal Robert McNamara in 1979. The fancy was to afford hypothecations to educeing countries on the mood that they adopted permitted negotiates by implementing a set reckon of policies, such as privatizations, service of flexile change rates, fissure up the negotiates to interexoteric excellent flows, decentralizing the admissionible bank, decreasing notorious and collective price… Scanty or none regard was consecrated to the detailities of the educeing economies (weight of secret and notorious sector, compatability of the negotiate to hold outer surprises, equalize of entrepreneurship etc), let quaint commemorative and other stipulations that mould and weigh-downt their footfootroute to outgrowth.

It was determined that their economies wanted big reforms in appoint for secret projects to be prolific. By that occasion, wide layer reforms were conceit to be advance causative than slender and restricted reforms. Yet, reformers aggravatelooked the circumstance that it is imlikely to do perfectthing at uniformly, due to flourishing a whiledrawal of notification. And so, the reforms that conclude from the top are out of feel astern a while the complexities at the groundexertion equalize. (Easterly, 2007)

These surprise therapy reforms led to greatly inaptitude and in sundry events, failed to boost the outaugmentation of the educeing economies, making them advance delicate on outer leanures and contingent on advance aid. Such was the event of the Côte d’Ivoire which ordinary 26 structural combination hypothecations in the mode of 10 years (from 1980s to 1990s). During that limit, the GDP per capita in the province contracted and the arrangement entered a limit of valley.

In remainder, Easterly (2007) thoughtful a reckon of African countries who ordinary sundry structural combination hypothecations in a indubitable limit and completed that they had inplain or naught outgrowth4. Why did that happened? For uniformly, indubitable African narrates were not cheerful to notorious up their negotiates to outer cannonade, nor did they possess a cheerful lie to occupation astern a while other countries. Furthermore, fissure up excellent negotiates did not cause an inrush of excellent as investors were advance thrilling in exploring African’s regular media (Stiglitz, 2007)

It is apt to wordslessness that as a repartee to the wants and contention generated by the reforms, the donors (IMF and Earth Bank) set-on-footed to purified the fancy of structural combination and re-named it to indigence abatement hypothecations. Yet, the standapex astern it (big-layer reforms, imlie of policies notwithstanding the animosity and variation of the economies) tarryed unaltered. 5

The want of such reforms exhibitions that a province is not an fancyhither entity, and thus cannot be theme to congruous policies that don’t possess into averment the inequitableities of the arrangement and the participation as a gross. In the signification of Easterly (2007): “[Aid bureaucracies] opt for allity rather than inequitableity, for earthwide «best customs» rather than what exertions in each locale”.


4 Latin American countries appeared to endure the selfselfcongruous necessity, astern a while the best limit of outaugmentation (1950-1980) entity featureized astern a while aver interposition and entrance situate anteriorly they set-on-footed to admit the hypothecations. See Easterly (2007) and Stiglitz (2007)

5 One in of such was Tanzania which ordinary a indigence abatement and outaugmentation readiness hypothecation from the IMF in 2000. In the lean exempt it was ordinary that the structural reforms (which were mooded to the hypothecation) aimed at deepening the financial and excellent negotiates, confirmation price coerce and commanding monetary policies to impair inflation. See IMF Approves Indigence Abatement and Outaugmentation Readiness Hypothecation for Tanzania, April 5, 2000, in

Contextualization as the new panacea for outgrowth?

Today’s junction of commemorative stipulations of outgrowth

The structural combination reforms exhibition us that the flourishing a whiledrawal of aim and scanty notification on the province wnear policies are implemented plain to bad remainders, proving that commemorative stipulations of outaugmentation reocean apt for the examine of outgrowth. Effectively, they explore the weigh-downts and challenges that a province has to countenance in continue of outgrowth, and they to-boot cause tail a detail and contextualizing mode, aggravatecoming the inefficiencies of rectirectirectistraight methodologies which arrogate perfect province has the selfselfcongruous stipulations of outgrowth.

How to put that into custom? Should outaugmentation practitioners merely examine province’s detailities and commemorative stipulations and pur-pose recognizeably? For request, anteriorly implementing measures such as decreasing notorious price they should be certified whether the population is greatly or scanty contingent on the aver for notorious movables and services victuals, and if tnear is space and compatability for secret cannonade to grasp the role of the aver in the victuals of such. Adding to that, comprehendledge environing the commemorativeal elucidation of a province could aid practitioners lowerstand why some countries are incapable to educe in a indubitable way, usually ined astern auspicious events, let it be China’s habit or European outaugmentation lower Industrial Revolution.

But so getting advance notification environing the inequitableities of countries, practitioners should to-boot afford way to those who comprehend advance environing the realities and quantitys societies countenance- the persons of those countries.

Overcoming popular arrears: allowing countries to eliminate own priorities and wants

In faithfulness, top-down modees to outgrowth, not barely endure from notification arrearss and notoriousizations, but they to-boot liberty scanty space for the population of the countries words their opinions and demands, twain having plain remainders on the outcomes of implemented policies. These issues are interlinked astern a while the comlie and erection of the organizations that mould outaugmentation policies, including the UN, Earth Bank and IMF.

Such institutions endure from a popular arrears in stipulations of resolution making, astern a while the richest narrates having advance bias and bargaining sway, astern a while some of them to-boot possessing sway of veto, having the lordship of resolutions (in the IMF, for request, the United Ordinary are the barely province astern a while an remainderive veto).

In this scenario, poopeace countries can’t words their opinions, let quaint save their interests. In sundry occasions, resolutions concerning reforms in indubitable educeing countries are graspn astern a whileout scanty feedtail from the plainers of those countries, whose delicate economies produce them recognize any stipulations in respin of a hypothecation.

It is thus indispensable to promise educeing countries in the resolution making appoint, in appoint not barely for the purpose of the remainderiveness of the projects, but to-boot to correct the popular principles of the institutions that dominate outaugmentation policies. As Stiglitz (2007) defends, it is nice to “[enhance] the rule of educeing countries to join-in meaningfully in resolution making, by providing them astern a while support in assessing the application on them of designed changes”.

Concluding Remarks

It is occasion for outaugmentation practitioners to exhibit that notoriousizations and all principles cannot be applied in a homogenous way, that countries are a erect of incongruous collective, economic and commemorative stipulations, and thus cannot be theme to rectirectirectistraight methodologies. Each province is the remainder of incongruous dynamics, and repugnant to what Rostow suggested, they can’t supervene the correspondently selfselfcongruous footfootroute to outaugmentation and outaugmentation as other narrates. Such establishedtys possess been a sordid custom, astern a while outaugmentation institutions neglecting the variation of the countries they exertion astern a while.

In the remotest condition of his illustrious exertion The Wealth and Indigence of Nations, David S. Landes (p 592, 1999) declares that narrative taught us the most auspicious treatments of indigence conclude from the within. Instead of commanding outer ins of outaugmentation to countries, one should decisively exhibit that what countries want are a terse management embezzle to their societies, and who in meliorate lie than the persons who feed tnear to erectulate such strategies?

Order a unique copy of this paper
(550 words)

Approximate price: $22

Basic features
  • Free title page and bibliography
  • Unlimited revisions
  • Plagiarism-free guarantee
  • Money-back guarantee
  • 24/7 support
On-demand options
  • Writer’s samples
  • Part-by-part delivery
  • Overnight delivery
  • Copies of used sources
  • Expert Proofreading
Paper format
  • 275 words per page
  • 12 pt Arial/Times New Roman
  • Double line spacing
  • Any citation style (APA, MLA, Chicago/Turabian, Harvard)

Our guarantees

Delivering a high-quality product at a reasonable price is not enough anymore.
That’s why we have developed 5 beneficial guarantees that will make your experience with our service enjoyable, easy, and safe.

Money-back guarantee

You have to be 100% sure of the quality of your product to give a money-back guarantee. This describes us perfectly. Make sure that this guarantee is totally transparent.

Read more

Zero-plagiarism guarantee

Each paper is composed from scratch, according to your instructions. It is then checked by our plagiarism-detection software. There is no gap where plagiarism could squeeze in.

Read more

Free-revision policy

Thanks to our free revisions, there is no way for you to be unsatisfied. We will work on your paper until you are completely happy with the result.

Read more

Privacy policy

Your email is safe, as we store it according to international data protection rules. Your bank details are secure, as we use only reliable payment systems.

Read more

Fair-cooperation guarantee

By sending us your money, you buy the service we provide. Check out our terms and conditions if you prefer business talks to be laid out in official language.

Read more

Calculate the price of your order

550 words
We'll send you the first draft for approval by September 11, 2018 at 10:52 AM
Total price:
The price is based on these factors:
Academic level
Number of pages